Month-to-Month vs. Annual Lease: Which Is Better for Landlords?

Print Friendly

Renting out your property is one of the best ways to invest in real estate. As a landlord, one of the key decisions you face when renting out your property is whether to offer a month-to-month lease or an annual lease. Each option comes with its advantages and disadvantages. Understanding them can help you make an informed choice that aligns with your goals and circumstances. 

It’s essential to explore the pros and cons of both month-to-month and annual leases, as it enables you to determine which option is better suited for you as a landlord.

What Are Month-to-Month Leases

A month-to-month lease is a rental agreement that allows tenants to rent a property on a monthly basis without a fixed-term commitment. Unlike annual leases, which typically span one year, month-to-month leases provide flexibility for tenants and landlords. It is because either party can terminate the lease with proper notice. 

Month-to-month leases offer convenience and adaptability. They are suitable for individuals requiring short-term housing or landlords who prefer the ability to change rental terms or adjust rent prices more frequently.

Advantages of Month-to-Month Leases

Here are a few benefits of renting your property on a month-to-month basis:

1. Flexibility

Month-to-month leases offer landlords enhanced flexibility, allowing them to modify rental terms, implement rent adjustments, or conclude the lease with adequate notice. Such flexibility proves beneficial when navigating unpredictable market conditions or when prompt adjustments to the property are necessary.

2. Easier Tenant Turnover

Month-to-month leases simplify the process of handling tenant turnover. Where challenging tenants arise or substantial property modifications are required, terminating the lease at the end of a month can be accomplished without breaching any long-term contractual obligations.

3. Higher Rent Potential

Month-to-month leases frequently require a higher rental premium compared to annual leases. The rationale lies in the tenants’ willingness to pay an additional amount for the flexibility and convenience that a shorter lease duration offers.

Disadvantages of Month-to-Month Leases

Month-to-month leases also come with disadvantages, including:

1. Inconsistent Income

Month-to-month leases carry the risk of inconsistent income for landlords. Tenants can move out on short notice, leaving the property vacant and requiring you to find new tenants quickly. This uncertainty can be challenging if you rely on a steady rental income.

2. Frequent Tenant Screening

Since tenants are free to relocate at any given time, landlords who opt for month-to-month leases must be prepared for more frequent tenant screenings. This undertaking can be laborious and potentially heighten the likelihood of inadvertently selecting unreliable or difficult tenants.

3. Increased Administrative Effort

With frequent tenant turnover, month-to-month leases often require more administrative effort. It includes preparing lease agreements more frequently, conducting move-in and move-out inspections, and managing security deposits.

What Are Annual Leases?

An annual lease, or a fixed-term lease, refers to a rental agreement that extends for one year. It establishes a contractual commitment between the tenant and landlord for a specific duration, during which the tenant agrees to rent the property. 

Unlike month-to-month leases, annual leases provide stability and predictability for both parties. It is because the terms and conditions, including the rent amount, are typically fixed for the duration of the lease. This type of lease is ideal for tenants seeking long-term housing and landlords who prefer consistent rental income and reduced turnover.

Benefits of Annual Leases

Here are a few reasons why you may want to consider renting out your property on an annual basis:

1. Stable Income

Opting for an annual lease offers landlords a steady and foreseeable income throughout the lease period. This assurance of having a committed tenant for a year enables effective financial planning and property management, fostering stability and predictability.

2. Reduced Tenant Turnover

With an annual lease, the turnover rate is lower since tenants are committed to the property for a fixed period. It means less time and effort spent finding new tenants and preparing the property for rent.

3. Reduced Administrative Tasks

Annual leases require less frequent administrative tasks compared to month-to-month leases. You only need to prepare the lease agreement, conduct inspections, and handle security deposits at least once a year.

Drawbacks of Annual Leases

Similar to month-to-month leases, annual leases also come with certain disadvantages, including:

1. Limited Flexibility

Annual leases offer less flexibility for landlords. If market conditions change or you need to adjust the rental terms, you’ll need to wait until the lease expires or mutually agree with the tenant for any modifications.

2. Difficult Tenant Removal 

If you have problematic tenants on an annual lease, removing them can be more challenging than with month-to-month leases. Eviction processes can be time-consuming. Also, you may have to wait until the lease term ends to take necessary action.

3. Potential Income Loss

If the market experiences an upward trend, landlords who opt for an annual lease might face the risk of not fully capitalizing on the opportunity to maximize their rental income. It is because the fixed rental rate throughout the lease term may hinder their ability to adapt to and benefit from the rising market prices.

How to Decide Between Annual and Month-to-Month Leases

Deciding between an annual lease and a month-to-month lease depends on various factors and considerations. Here are some factors you need to consider to help you make an informed decision:

Long-Term Goals

Consider your long-term plans for the property. If you prefer stability and consistent income, an annual lease might be more suitable. On the other hand, if you anticipate changes or potential opportunities in the near future, a month-to-month lease can offer the flexibility you need.

Rental Market Dynamics

To make an informed decision, it is crucial to assess the rental market in your specific area. In a fiercely competitive market with upward-moving rental prices, choosing an annual lease can ensure a higher rent rate throughout the entire lease duration. 

However, in an uncertain or volatile market, a month-to-month lease offers the advantage of being able to make more frequent rent adjustments to align with the prevailing market conditions.

Tenant Turnover

Evaluate your willingness to manage tenant turnover. Month-to-month leases may result in more frequent tenant changes, requiring additional effort for screening, inspections, and finding new tenants. 

If you prefer a more stable and hands-off approach, an annual lease with reduced turnover may be preferable.

Flexibility Needs

Consider how much flexibility you require as a landlord. Month-to-month leases offer the flexibility to make changes to rental terms, increase rent, or terminate the lease with proper notice. 

Annual leases, while less flexible, provide a stable rental arrangement with fewer administrative tasks and the assurance of a longer-term commitment.

Legal and Regulatory Considerations

Familiarize yourself with local laws and regulations regarding lease terms and tenant rights. Some jurisdictions may impose restrictions on lease duration or notice periods for terminating leases. Ensure you comply with the legal requirements applicable to your area.

Financial Considerations

Evaluate your financial goals and requirements. An annual lease offers more predictable and consistent income, which can benefit financial planning. 

On the other hand, a month-to-month lease may provide the potential for higher rental income through periodic adjustments or premium rates.

Seek Professional Advice

Consult with real estate professionals or property management experts who can provide insights based on local market conditions and their industry expertise. They can help you analyze your situation and guide you toward the most suitable lease option.

Bottom Line

Deciding between a month-to-month lease and an annual lease as a landlord necessitates a thoughtful evaluation of multiple factors. Ultimately, the choice between these lease options relies on your inclinations, prevailing market circumstances, and your long-term aspirations as a landlord.

It may also be worthwhile to consult with real estate professionals or property management experts to gain further insights and make an informed decision that best suits your specific circumstances.

Source: Landlord Gurus