Legal

Only AAOA Pro, Pro Plus and VIP Members are able to access legal cases.

Landlord-Tenant Law

Delshah 60 Ninth, LLC v. Free People of PA LLC May 5, 2026

A dispute arose between a commercial landlord and tenant after government emergency orders during the COVID-19 pandemic required non-essential businesses in New York City to close. The tenant, operating a retail clothing store in Manhattan, stopped paying rent, arguing that

Bozzuto Management Co. v. Craig April 30, 2026

The case involves a tenant, Ms. Craig, who uses a wheelchair and lived in an apartment managed and owned by the appellants. Her rent was paid through a D.C. housing voucher, but she was responsible for utilities and parking. The

Kapneck 14-16 v. Breezy’s Speakeasy April 29, 2026

A commercial tenant operating a beer and wine store in Maryland entered into a five-year lease requiring it to pay base rent as well as additional charges—including real estate taxes, water and sewer bills, late fees, HVAC replacement costs, and

Commission on Human Rights & Opportunities ex rel. Pizzoferrato v. Mansions, LLC April 24, 2026

The plaintiffs, including a state commission and two tenants, alleged that the owner and management of an apartment complex discriminated against them by refusing to allow two emotional support dogs, despite a general no-pet policy. The tenants had previously lived

Vivos Xpoint v. Sindorf April 23, 2026

A California company repurposed decommissioned military bunkers in South Dakota as survival shelters, offering them for sale or long-term lease. In 2020, an individual entered into a 99-year lease with the company for one of these bunkers, paying $35,000 upfront.

Real Estate & Property Law

Article 13 LLC v. LaSalle NationalBank Ass’n May 13, 2026

A junior mortgage holder sought to quiet title against a senior mortgage on a Brooklyn property, arguing that the senior mortgage had become unenforceable under New York’s six-year statute of limitations. The senior mortgage had been accelerated by the filing

Butts v. Mace May 13, 2026

Two groups of plaintiffs challenged the road maintenance fees imposed by Orangeburg and Georgetown Counties, arguing these fees constituted invalid taxes under South Carolina law as interpreted in a prior decision. Both counties had long-standing ordinances requiring an annual fee

BMK Enterprises v. Bailey May 12, 2026

BMK Enterprises purchased a commercial property from Bailey Enterprises in 2018. As part of the transaction, the parties agreed to a provision granting BMK a right of first refusal if Bailey decided to sell the adjacent Bolinger Property, which contained

Martens v. BB’s Childcare May 8, 2026

A property owner initiated a forcible entry and detainer action in county court against tenants who allegedly failed to pay rent on a commercial lease. The lease included options for the tenants to purchase the property during future terms, granted

Bonin v. Sabine River Authority May 7, 2026

A catastrophic storm in March 2016 caused unprecedented rainfall in the Sabine River basin, leading the operators of the Toledo Bend Dam—jointly managed by the Sabine River Authority of Texas and the Sabine River Authority, State of Louisiana—to open nine