Tips for tenant screening

Tenant screening helps minimize the risk of renting to high-risk applicants.

As a landlord, you can create tenant interest by writing an effective rental listing. It’s common for landlords to make this huge mistake: only requiring a rental application and meeting their tenant at a showing. This method leaves room for error when deciding if a prospective tenant is qualified. Here are a few things to be mindful of and include in your screening process.

  • Man reviewing credit report Shutterstock_496591324 Let the prospective tenant know that you do require a tenant background check.
  • Provide the potential tenant an avenue to apply either online or on paper.
  • Perform a screening of the applicant and evaluate it.
  • Meet the potential tenant in person, if possible, to evaluate:
    • Inconsistent answers
    • Reluctance to complete a credit or background check
    • Delayed communication or expressing disinterest
    • Disrespectful behavior at your property showing

It is important to create a consistent screening process that honors all Fair Housing Act laws that protect tenants from discrimination. Some of these laws include protected classes such as gender, family status, sex, disability, national origin, religion, color and race. Talk to a lawyer if you have questions.

How can I check a tenant’s credit?

There are several ways to get a tenant credit report, but the easiest solution is using an online service. As soon you enter their email, they’ll receive a notification asking them to authorize the reports by entering their Social Security Number. Shortly after, you’ll get an email stating that the report is ready to be viewed.

Is the tenant financially responsible?

Credit scores range from 350 to 800. Typically, the higher someone’s score is, the more financially responsible they are. Beyond the credit score, credit reports reveal even more information: red flags, account summaries and tradelines.

  • Red flags are typically indications of potential fraud, and this information is gathered based on a tenant’s residence history and employer info.
  • You’ll be able to view a tenant’s current monthly balances organized by account type and their current debt load.
  • And last, you’ll view a tradeline of each open account complete with payment status, so you know whether they have a history of making payments on time.

Free Rental Application

Get 20 Rental Forms for FREE, including a rental application.


What can be considered in a decision?

As a landlord, you’re allowed to decline a tenant for not having enough income, not being financially responsible or having too many financial obligations to afford your rent price.

However, you’re required to tell a tenant if you’re rejecting them due to information on their credit report, according to the Fair Credit Reporting Act. This gives tenants the opportunity to dispute any information on the credit report with the credit bureau.

Before making your final decision, we also recommend requesting two more important reports: background and eviction reports. With all three reports, you’ll get a complete view of who your applicant is.

  • Credit reports tell you how your applicant treats creditors and their finances
  • Tenant background checks tell you how they treat society and neighbors
  • Eviction reports tell you how they’ve treated prior landlords

Tenant insurance

In some cases, landlords may want to verify the applicant is obtaining or has renters insurance to protect their personal belongings and any damage to the property. Like a tenant’s credit score, requiring proof of renters insurance might be an indicator of a potential tenant’s ability to pay rent on time.

Source: State Farm