How to Avoid Common Landlord Tenant Dispute

The definition of normal wear and tear and damage is often a sticking point between landlords and tenants.

The property managers at REI Liaison in St. Louis have some tips to help defuse those tense discussions:

Normal Wear and Tear vs Damage

As a landlord state law allows you to collect a security deposit, but the deposit must be refundable if the property is in the same condition as move in, minus normal wear and tear.

This means landlords may only charge tenants for damage done to the property.

Here are a few examples of normal wear:

Worn carpet and linoleum
Cracks in walls caused by settling
Faded or blistered paint

Here are examples of damage:

Stained carpet and linoleum
Holes and dents in walls caused by accidents or carelessness
Drawings on walls or unapproved painting by tenant

Although normal wear and tear vs. damage can be hard to define, there are a few things you can do to protect yourself from any confusion.

As with most things, communication is the key: if both you and your tenants are clear about the condition of the unit at move-in, the importance of promptly reporting needed repairs, and expectations at move-out, the tenancy and the end of the tenancy will be smoother.

Insist on a walk-through with new tenants. At the walk-through the tenants will have an opportunity to note in writing existing damage and wear and tear in the rental. Also, take dated photographs to keep on file. This way both the landlord and tenant are protected. The tenant can’t be charged for damage that was not documented in the walk through, and the landlord has picture proof of the unit’s condition at move in.

Have your lease outline the requirements for taking care of the property and promptly calling for any repairs needed. Make the tenants aware if they do not not notify the landlord in a timely manner of any issues, they can be charged for any damage that occurred from their negligence. Make your contact information readily available to the tenants, such as a business card, fridge magnet, or website.

Before move-out refer tenants to the Wear and Tear versus Damages document and cleaning checklist. This way the tenant knows what is expected of them in preparation for move out and cleaning of the unit.

REI Liaison is a full service residential Property Management and Leasing company serving property owners in the St. Louis area.

With AAOA, landlords have resources at their fingertips. Check out our new Landlord Forms Page.

American Apartment Owners Association offers discounts on products and services for landlords related to your rental housing investment, including rental forms, tenant debt collection, tenant background checks, insurance and financing. Find out more at