Open/Close Menu
Your Rental Housing Solution
Home · Property Management · Latest News : Landlords Sue Over “Tenant Education” Forms

judgeTwo Athens, Georgia landlords are heading back to court to contest a controversial city ordinance that requires area landlords to obtain signed “education forms” from every tenant. 

The city requires the forms to teach tenants certain civic responsibilities, concerning such topics as trash collection, littering, and occupancy limitations.

This case went to trial court last year.  The judge sided with the landlords in finding that the law violated landlords’ equal protection rights, because it applied only to those landlords who owned 10 units or less. As written, the ordinance effectively exempts the local university from the reporting requirement even though a city official claimed that the intent behind the ordinance is to educate students regarding city rules and services.

The judge found no credible reason why larger landlords should be exempt from the requirement.  At the same time, he determined that the rest of the ordinance was valid and could be enforced with changes.

The city began to enforce the ordinance with respect to larger apartment complexes, and recently filed new charges against the landlords.

The two are appealing the judge’s decision in the hope that an appellate court will find the entire ordinance unconstitutional and toss it out.  They also argue that the ordinance requires them to break state privacy laws, and punishes landlords if tenants refuse to comply.

Athens was the site of a similar battle a few years ago when the city passed a zoning restriction which required all landlords to file reports on tenants  indicating whether they were single or married.  The law was designed to keep unmarried people, many of whom were students, from renting homes in established neighborhoods.

That law prompted the state legislature to pass a bill prohibiting any city in Georgia from requiring landlords to obtain such private information.  The bill included a provision prohibiting rental property inspections unless the city found reasonable cause to believe there was a safety hazard on the property.

With AAOA, landlords have resources at their fingertips.   Check out our Helpful Links page.

American Apartment Owners Association offers discounts on products and services for landlords related to your rental housing investment, including rental forms, tenant debt collection, tenant background checks, insurance and financing. Find out more at www.joinaaoa.org.

  • brassservices

    The ordinance appears to also violate a fundamental need of food, shelter and clothing of the residents; something which We the People have a Natural Right to have without undue and unreasonable restrictions.

    It begs a question of liability on the part of a landlord; if an unconstitutional law is passed and the landlord knowingly and willingly complies with its provisions even knowing that it violates the inalienable rights of the citizens, are they retroactively liable in a civil setting for damages. After all, if the citizenry has a duty to protest and deny bad laws (see Rosa Parks sitting on a bus), then doesn’t the same principle apply to corporations and others who continually demand the same rights as individuals?

  • steve

    I WOULD SAY THE LANDLORDS WERE COVERED BY THE COURTS,AS ENFORCING THE LAW. WOULDNT THEIR LIABILITY INS COVER THEM? THEY CAN’T BE PUNISHED FOR ENFORCING THE LAW, AND PROBABLY FILE SUIT IMMEDIATELY WITH THE A.C.L.U. TO HELP THEM

Copyright © 2004 - 2016 AAOA.com. All Rights Reserved.